Entertainment
The New Star Wars Boss Already Has Three Strikes Against Him
By Chris Snellgrove
| Published
Even amongst the true faithful of the Star Wars fandom, the verdict on The Mandalorian and Grogu seems to be “good, but not great.” True to its pedigree as an adaptation of a TV show, it feels less like a feature film than a handful of episodes stapled together. Sure, it provides plenty of action and cool moments with its titular characters, but that’s not enough. Audiences agree, which is why this movie had the lowest opening weekend ever recorded for a Star Wars live-action film. It’s still earning far more than the lowest earner in the franchise: The Clone Wars movie, which preceded the acclaimed TV show of the same name.
Those movies are very distinct. They feature different characters, different plots, and are made for two entirely different mediums (live-action and animation). But they do have one major thing in common: they were each written by Dave Filoni, who has recently replaced Kathleen Kennedy and became President and Chief Creative Officer of Lucasfilm. Many cynical fans were all too happy to see Kennedy go, but it’s far too early to celebrate. Considering that Filoni was also a writer and executive producer for the much-maligned series The Book of Boba Fett, the failure of The Mandalorian and Grogu means the new Star Wars boss already has three strikes against him!
Space Cowboy
Even before this latest Star Wars movie, Dave Filoni was becoming a controversial figure within the fandom. He gained early praise as showrunner for The Clone Wars, which is rightfully considered some of the best Star Wars media ever made. He then created Rebels, another fan-favorite cartoon in a galaxy far, far away. But as Filoni got more creative control within the franchise, his work became increasingly self-referential. He ensured that shows like The Mandalorian and The Book of Boba Fett included callbacks to his own characters and turned Ahsoka into a live-action Rebels sequel. While this thrilled Filoni’s fans, it worried critics who thought he had lost the ability to truly innovate.
Still, Filoni has more hits than misses, so he was recently promoted to President and Chief Creative Officer of Lucasfilm. This seemed like a good idea on paper because Filoni has a strong history of creating beloved TV shows, which have been the primary form of Star Wars content for many years. However, Disney now wants to pivot Star Wars back to the big screen, and The Mandalorian and Grogu was their first new movie in the franchise since 2019. However, this Filoni-written film fizzled. It has a relatively low 62 percent on Rotten Tomatoes and is well on its way to earning the lowest box office of any Star Wars film.
His Failure Is Now Complete
That would be the worst box office failure for the franchise since Star Wars: The Clone Wars hit theaters in 2008. That movie (replete with Hutt fart jokes, no less) was also written and even directed by Dave Filoni. It has an abysmal 18 percent on Rotten Tomatoes and earned only $68.5 million at the box office. By comparison, The Mandalorian and Grogu is going to earn far more money, but its earnings will still fall short of every live-action film before it. Two films is a pattern, and the simple truth is that Dave Filoni’s involvement is officially the kiss of death for Star Wars movies.
That’s bad news considering that he’s the new Star Wars boss and there are new franchise films (like the very buzzy Starfighter) in development. At this point, Filoni’s fans will point out that he’s still got the golden touch when it comes to TV shows in a galaxy far, far away. It’s true that Filoni still mostly has the goods in this arena (Ahsoka was solid, and Maul–Shadow Lord is downright brilliant), but he was also extensively involved in The Book of Boba Fett, a terrible series that wasted one of the franchise’s most beloved villains.
When you factor in the failure of both this show and the Clone Wars movie, it’s easy to see that The Mandalorian and Grogu is the third strike for Filoni. Unfortunately, he hasn’t struck out. Instead, he’s now got more power over the Star Wars universe than anyone since George Lucas. Will he lead the franchise into a new golden age or deliver something even fouler than baby Rotta? Only time will tell, but after the disappointment of The Mandalorian and Grogu, a growing number of fans are all saying the same thing: I’ve got a bad feeling about this.