As holiday shopping kicks off in earnest, you’ve probably noticed that the new AirPods 4 come in two variants: one with active noise cancellation (ANC) and one without. But the question is, how do they compare to the AirPods 3?

It’s time for a good ol’ AirPods 4 vs. AirPods 3 face-off, which will help you decide how they differ and whether the fourth-generation AirPods are worth the upgrade.

Or perhaps you’ve never owned AirPods and you’re wondering whether you should purchase the newest pair or grab its predecessor. No matter where you are in your purchase journey, we can help you through it with this in-depth comparative analysis of both the AirPods 4 and AirPods 3.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Price and availability

The AirPods 4, as mentioned at the outset, comes in two flavors: ANC and no ANC.

AirPods 3
Credit: Mashable

The non-ANC model normally starts at $129.99, tough it’s on sale for $119.99 for Black Friday. However, if you want the model with ANC, you’ll have to shell out $179.99, which is $50 more.

The AirPods 4 offers an affordable entry point compared to the AirPods 3 that launched in 2021 with a starting price of $179.99.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Design

We interviewed two head honchos from the Apple team about the AirPods 4’s design, specifically Eric Treski, Director of AirPods Product Marketing at Apple, and Kate Bergeron, the Vice President of Hardware Engineering at Apple. They acknowledged that the AirPods line has a fit inconsistency hurdle that Apple has been struggling to overcome. Some users say that their AirPods fit just fine, but others say that they keep falling out.

AirPods 4
Credit: Apple

That said, the AirPods 4 has a new design that has the best fit for most. How did the company manage to accomplish this? Apple said that it did extensive research on ear shapes. “We’ve come up with a relatively efficient way to scan people’s ears through our own tools so we can build that database [and continue to find the ‘best fit’] on an ongoing basis,” Bergeron said.

As such, compared to other AirPods on the market, the AirPods 4 should be the most comfortable. The AirPods 4 have shaved-down stems and slimmer, more angular inserts compared to the AirPods 3. (The latter has larger, more bulbous inserts.) The new-generation AirPods are also slightly smaller than the AirPods 3, but they both weigh about the same (i.e., 0.15 ounces).

AirPods 3
Credit: Mashable

AirPods fit is subjective, but speaking anecdotally, the AirPods 4 fit very well — even better than the AirPods Pro that I own. No matter how much I shake my head, they don’t fall out.

Additionally, unlike the AirPods Pro line, the AirPods 4 continue to not have silicone ear tips.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: ANC, Transparency Mode, and Adaptive Audio

On the AirPods 3, you won’t find support for ANC, Transparency Mode, nor Adaptive Audio whatsoever.

AirPods 4
Credit: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable

However, Apple changed that with the AirPods 4. The base model doesn’t offer any of the aforementioned features, but the pricier variant comes with all three.

In our interview with Apple, Treski explained that putting ANC in “open-air earbuds,” meaning earbuds that don’t have silicone tips like the AirPods Pro line, is quite tricky. The silicone tips act as passive noise cancellation tools because they’re blocking your ear canal from external noise, and they work in concert with hardware (like the H2 chip) and software to cancel out incoming noise.

Apple admitted that the H2 chip has to work a little harder on the AirPods 4 to cancel out noise, but anecdotally, I can confirm that it works like a charm. Of course, no ANC headphones can completely eradicate noise, but in an airport, the AirPods 4 heavily subdued noises like chatty conversations and PA announcements. If I wanted to hear those PA announcements, I could turn on Transparency Mode. You can also use Adaptive Audio, which requires you to trust that the AirPods 4 can swap between ANC and Transparency Modes by intelligently determining whether the external noises are worth hearing. Sometimes it gets it right, sometimes it doesn’t, so I prefer to swap between Transparency and ANC modes myself.

AirPods 4
Credit: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable

On the plane itself, AirPods 4 with ANC worked well in getting rid of some of the higher-pitched sounds that emanated from the plane — a cacophonous sound that, if you’ll permit me to use onomatopoeia, sounds like a “whishing” noise. But with the lower “humming” sounds of the engine, I could still hear them through the AirPods 4 with ANC. Overall, though, for a pair of open-air earbuds, the AirPods 4 with ANC does a great job at active noise cancellation.

It also helps that, as Apple told Mashable in an interview, the AirPods 4 with ANC borrows microphones from the AirPods Pro 2, which Apple says are “high quality” and contribute to the AirPods 4’s success with ANC.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Touch controls

With the AirPods 4 with ANC, you can press and hold the stem to toggle between ANC, Transparency, and Adaptive Audio modes. You can also finagle between the modes on your iPhone. (If you have an Android, you can’t select ANC options on your phone; you’ll have to rely on the touch controls.)

AirPods 4
Credit: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable

Touch controls you can find on the AirPods 3 and AirPods 4 include the following:

• Play/pause: press the stem

• Play next track: Double-press the stem

• Play the previous track: Triple-press the stem

• Answer calls: press the stem

Unfortunately, however, both models still lack on-bud volume controls, which is a common user complaint.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Sound quality

According to our review of the AirPods 3, these buds are already pretty impressive.

Credit: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable

However, in my experience, the AirPods 4 takes it up a notch. I listened to my favorite song of the year, “Espresso,” on AirPods 4 with ANC, and it felt as if Sabrina Carpenter was singing the song right in front of me in a soundproof cafe.

The AirPods 4 (ANC and non-ANC models) and the AirPods 3 have support for Personalized Spatial Audio, which means that, depending on your ears, the earbuds offer the best customized listening experience designed for you. However, the AirPods 4 takes it up a notch because it adds an improved amplifier and driver, which leads to better bass, and clearer mids and highs.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Siri Interactions

The AirPods 4, whether they have ANC or not, support something called Siri Interactions.

AirPods 3
Credit: Mashable

Siri Interactions, which are not available on the AirPods 3, allow you to nod yes or shake your head no to questions or statements from Siri. For example, when Siri tells you there’s an incoming call, you can nod to take the call or shake your head to reject it.

This allows you to have a hands-free experience wit your AirPods 4.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Case

The AirPods 4 case got a slight makeover. It’s the smallest AirPods case that Apple has ever produced. So if you’ve been dreaming of an even more pocketable pair of AirPods, the AirPods 4 is the one for you. This new AirPods 4 case ships for both models: ANC and non-ANC.

AirPods 3
Credit: Mashable

It’s also worth noting that, on the AirPods 4 case, you won’t find the same pairing button that was featured on the AirPods 3’s case. I learned the hard way that it’s not there anymore. (I was scratching my head trying to find it for far too long — until I discovered that there’s a new pairing button that’s now hidden.) The pairing button has been replaced with a capacitive touch feature on the front. So when you open the case (with the AirPods 4 in them), you’ll see a green light, which indicates the battery status is in good standing. Double tap on that light until you get a blinking white light, which will allow you to initiate pairing mode, so you can connect the AirPods 4 to your device.

Another difference is that the AirPods 4 case now has a BLE (Bluetooth Low Energy) radio inside it, allowing you to find the case independently from the buds in case you lose them.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Battery life

We don’t have in-house testing for the AirPods 3, but according to Apple, they last up to six hours on a single charge.

AirPods 4
Credit: Kimberly Gedeon / Mashable

We did, however, test the AirPods 4; it lasted 5 hours and 12 minutes. (This almost matches Apple’s own rating; the Cupertino-based tech giant said it can survive for up to 5 hours on a single charge.) In my experience, Apple’s claims typically match Mashable’s own runtime figures, so there’s a good chance that you’ll squeeze out more battery life out of the AirPods 3, which has a six-hour battery life rating, compared to the AirPods 4.

Apple AirPods 4 vs AirPods 3: Which should you buy?

If you’re looking for the best value, the AirPods 4 offers more bang for your buck, particularly the ANC model. You get Siri Interactions, a more findable and compact charging case, and improved bass, mids, and highs.

However, the AirPods 3 — while lacking ANC — still delivers solid sound quality and reliable battery life. So, if you’re all about advanced features and noise cancellation AirPods 4 is the way to go. But if you prefer a simple, proven pair of earbuds, the AirPods 3 will still hold up.